Bravely Default Time Mage
Jillian
What is happening here? Ladies, only because she has slightly less ridiculousness strapped to her face.
Joey
Ladies. But both are offensive to the eye and have a motion capture vibe to them. This is not a good vibe to be having.
Erin
Ladies. He’s heavy and clunky looking and she’s more refined/streamlined. I like less bulk.
Winner: Ladies
Final Fashionista 
Neither? They both look nearly the same to me. I trying to decide if they look better than time mages from Final Fantasy Tactics. Those guys and gals looked like clowns.
The crazy thing is, these outfits are probably closer to “high fashion” than a lot of the others we’ve looked at! E.g. they’d be right at home alongside stuff like this: http://media-cache-ec0.pinimg.com/236x/83/98/c5/8398c522f372e334a5a0e6cdcf29ab00.jpg / http://www.debutanteclothing.com/news/images/viktorrolfparis.jpg